Of course, being the attention hound that I am, I went through HN’s karma leaders to see what their feed UX was like, figuring I’d call out a few people to get some attention & upvotes. But wow, what a sorry bunch. Finding issues is like shooting fish in a barrel.

Before I begin, a shout out: ColinWright, you are literally the only one with decent-looking feed. Way to go! Everybody else, well, let’s just say there is room for improvement. I made some before & (potential) after links in the example section on the Feed.style home page.

So, on with naming & shaming: tptacek/fly.io (bad self link, no discovery link), jacquesm (bad self link), davewiner (no self link), danso (insecure self link), tosh (self link mismatch, though it does work), luu (bad self link)...

And the internet elders? Worst of all. If there could be one way of dealing with news feeds worse than a wall of text, what would it be? Popping up the “Save as…” dialog. I’m looking at you: mnot, tbray, jgrahamc, aphyr, thomaspark… Seriously, it doesn’t matter if you use the standard content type if it makes the UX this unfriendly. And yes, I’m using Firefox: aren’t you?

On a serious note: I am a big fan of RSS & think it has a ton of potential, but we have to do better or it will remain a geeks-only sideshow.