I read Dharmesh Shah's "Lamenting the Loss of Reddit" at onstartups.com, which furter fueled a notion that's been brewing for some time now.
When does the Wisdom of Crowds become Herd Mentality? And why? The easy answer is that with wider adoption it's inevitable. Early adopters are, I would propose, more interesting people, generally, than later waves of mass market users.
If you're a social media startup is it an unconscious goal to make your community boring? Are Paris Hilton threads a sign of success?
This is only a thought stub, put out quickly. I'm interested to know what others think about this.